Skip to content
Advertisements

Arnold Kling vs. Paul Romer vs. Bruno Leoni

August 10, 2009

Arnold Kling writes:

Paul Romer, in presenting his idea for charter cities, makes it sound as though we can take rules “manufactured” in, say, Canada, and export them anywhere in the world. Leoni would say that instead most law is embedded in social customs In fact, my daughter who just spent the summer in Tanzania, says that the custom of seeing law as something that ought to be obeyed is not nearly as natural there as it is here.

Not quite. Romer seems quite cognizant of the fact that you can’t just take Senegal’s legal code, replace it with Canada’s, and expect things to be peachy. If you’ve watched Romer’s TED talk, you’ll recall the image of those African students, all of whom probably have cell phones, studying under streetlights. The reason these students don’t have power in their homes is because of price controls that disincentivize power companies from supplying more people with power . And Romer notes that the political class in these countries is aware that these laws suck, but can’t change them because there are existing, entrenched interests that benefit from the existence of these laws.

Deng Xiaoping was facing the same situation. He went to places like Singapore, and saw that Communism didn’t work. But rather than replace communism with another system in one fell swoop, he created special economic zones where people could self-select to try a new system, and over time, there was incremental reform throughout the country in the direction of more economic freedom and respect for private property. Customs may not interchangeable, but they can evolve over time.

Romer wants charter cities to be built on uninhabited land for a number of very good reasons. One of them is that he sees them as a kind of intentional community – a city in which people self-select to try and live under a new set of rules. It’s because laws cannot be easily exported that Romer is trying to create new jurisdictions to experiment with new laws, rather than trying to convince leaders in established jurisdictions to adopt better laws.


Advertisements
9 Comments
  1. August 10, 2009 7:20 pm

    But if part of these rules include generous European-style social safety nets, then selection may be adverse instead of advantageous. Romer manages to defend charter cities as not being neo-colonialism, but unless some serious positive selection for migrants takes place, I am not certain that they can succeed in creating foreign institutions any better than the colonizers did.

  2. May 7, 2012 5:15 pm

    Mes remerciements pour cet exercice. On en souhaiterait un peu plus convi� avec tant de tact.

  3. May 13, 2014 12:21 am

    COROLLARY: Employers are seldom if ever waiting for your resume or application.

    That evolved into eventually attending Bhartendu Natya
    Academy of Dramatic Arts, Lucknow. The best resume that I have ever seen was in one of
    the editions of What Color is Your Parachute.

  4. June 2, 2014 4:25 am

    Not all teenagers are that rich enough to spend money on apparels in order to catch up with these trends.
    The boxes are offered in various sizes, thus one can have special tiny and cute box to put the ring in it or
    at the same time heavy trinkets can be kept safe in artistic big boxes.
    They rely on more 140 suppliers worldwide, with each region specializing in a
    certain type of clothing that it can manufacture at a competitive
    price.

  5. June 9, 2014 12:47 pm

    Just give both methods a try and see which one
    you like the best. It is the dream of every person to have a nice and glowing skin without dark spots.
    Use them to whip up a quick batch of muffins that even your gluten eaters
    will enjoy. Or you can convert ice cubes into crushed ice-cubes for frosty
    drinks. While the Blendtec Blender is compact, sleek,
    modern and very high tech with a lit up LCD Screen, soft push programmable
    and pre-programmed buttons. In fact Gordon has chosen to endorse the Bamix by putting his name to
    one of the Bamix top of the range models The Gordon Ramsay Signature Edition. Unfortunately, it wouldn’t be practical to buy a certain product just to test
    it and return it days after usage. The live band starts
    around 9pm and they do take requests. The
    only real cleaning that will need to be done is the food processor and hopefully there are others around to do that job.
    They are among the most popular appliances in the kitchen. When everything’s good
    and hot turn back to variable speed low and then flip the
    dial down again to 1. Breakfast (‘break’ the ‘fast’) breaks that cycle and keeps your metabolism normalized.
    It’s nice to have some variety in your breakfast, so switch it up between these low fat breakfast recipes.
    The long-term service means you don’t be required to worry,
    but whenever you see how well-made it is, you’ll probably feel reassured that investment was
    a wise one. And building one yourself is put into question here whether it can be cost effective.

  6. June 13, 2014 11:05 pm

    In this way, the report presents a complete and coherent analysis of the Chinese cosmetics industry.
    Even with their marketing strategy based solely
    on word-of-mouth, MAC has managed to be a global
    giant generating $250 million annually by 1997 and eventually sold the Company to another
    Cosmetic giant, Estee Lauder, now generating $500 million in sales.
    A few of us might think that if the cosmetics from MAC are
    providing the best quality of cosmetics then how they can charge their cosmetics likely to the cheap cosmetics company.
    The cosmetics industry is, in fact, a self-regulated one, which means your
    safety isn’t going to be a priority ‘ sales are. Also, as the country has a large
    consumer base, manufacturers can easily tap the domestic market.
    Applying colors like teal, fuschia, green or orange can make the eye area look
    rather inflamed. The report facilitates analysis of various industry segments, i.
    Then, using good quality white tissue paper,
    wipe your forehead, cheeks, nose and chin individually and examine the tissue.
    We can take care of our beauty entirely with natural recipes from an early age and thanks
    to the creativity of a good beautician to prevent all problems, as we
    mature. While children can use them to carry their books, stationary and lunch; adults find them ideal for
    carrying cell phones, business cards, and cosmetics.
    Dolce & Gabbana (D&G), Giorgio Armani, L’Oreal, Calvin Klein, Maybelline New York, Prada, Jean Paul Gaultier and many more.
    For one, mint cosmetics uses sodium bicarbonate – a much milder cleansing agent than hydrogen peroxide ‘
    which might be useful for people with allergies, but does not deliver on promises
    of fast teeth whitening. Cosmetics are not a necessity, but they are a luxury that is a
    minimal expense in light of the benefits that cosmetics award a woman. As a result, the global male skin care market which was only worth
    about US$ 193 Million in 2009 is now growing at a
    substantial rate of about 16% annually. You can get lost
    in the wide choices that are made available by this reputed cosmetics brand but the talented employees are
    sure to help users find a way out of this maze.

  7. July 2, 2014 2:47 pm

    The key is to add a pop of color in your footwear selection. This is also considered the favorite
    of Lindsay Lohan. You are sitting on a guilt chair in the grand salon of a pallazzo in Rome and watching Valentino present his alta moda collection.

  8. July 3, 2014 8:34 am

    Regardless of the quality of the application, it is the owner who makes
    the final decision to accept or reject the prospective
    tenant. These pension funds include both those owned by the Government or
    by large corporations. Based on irrigating 230 days a year, this
    is the amount of water needed, and he neither drinks it or baths in it.
    ANY PERSON WHO HAS QUESTIONS CONCERNING ANY AGENDA
    ITEM MAY CALL THE CITY CLERK AT 209-388-7100 TO ASK ABOUT THE ITEM DESCRIBED
    ON THE AGENDA. So which forms of solar energy have the best short-term and long-term economic potential.
    Inspect units, approve lease and execute the Housing Assistance
    Payment. Unfortunately, there are very few one size
    fits all risks for real estate investing, as each type of investing is
    inherently different. With all of the mortgages
    and loans available to homeowners and real estate investors,
    the banks and mortgage companies have grown tremendously over the past fifty years.
    Leasehold interests are conveyed by an apartment lease. Everyone would
    be happy to make each other’s acquaintance.

  9. July 3, 2014 9:23 pm

    Sol’Exotica’s tanning salons Mississauga offer a variety of tanning solutions for all preferences, including tanning beds and sunless spray
    tan Mississauga booths. Sunless tanning spray solutions contain a chemical known as dihydroxyacetone or DHA, which darkens the tone of the skin,
    simulating the effects of a natural tan. Sunless spray tanning booths have emerged as one of the
    most popular tanning options especially among people who don’t tan easily or fair
    skinned people who get burns because of over exposure to
    the sun or for that matter anyone who wants the perfect sun kissed look without going out in the sun. Each requires the proper lotion to
    effectively tan. The best part is that their products
    are very easy to apply and are made of completely natural ingredients.
    This type of nail treatment will give you great colour
    without chipping, so even if you have them done a few days before the event they
    will still look good. However, the World Health Organization recently added tanning beds to the
    top tier of lethal carcinogens, right up there with tobacco, arsenic, and hepatitis B.
    The entire spray tanning process is over in less than a minute.

    Care should be taken while applying the spray to ensure that it does not fall on your hands and feet
    because you can get a white vein like look due to the presence
    of excess wrinkles and creases in these areas. After you have completely dried out, give yourself 8-10 hours before stepping inside the shower.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: