Skip to content

The United States of Insurance

April 12, 2010

At the Dilbert blog, Scott Adams stumbles his way towards competitive governance. He proposes privatizing government by replacing our current system with an insurance-based model:

In step one of this hypothetical future, the government of the United States buys every insurance company in the country at estimated current values. In this imagined future, the government becomes the insurance provider for the country, and perhaps the rest of the world. The profits from selling insurance will eventually replace taxes. Our government would become a for-profit enterprise…

The biggest leap of faith in this thought experiment is that the government could do anything right. But consider that 90% of private businesses eventually go belly up. If you could measure the performance of your government the way you measure the performance of private companies – by profits, and the government leaders themselves had a profit motive, how efficient could government become? The United States of Insurance would allow that sort of profit measurement and incentive.

There’s no reason to assume monopoly control here. In the absence of a competitive market, it is misguided (to put it mildly) to assume USG management would be more efficient at managing all private insurance firms. Why not allow insurance companies to compete across state lines? Is there an individual mandate? What are the fines for not complying? Who imposes them?


One Comment
  1. April 12, 2010 5:39 pm

    This is interesting thought construction (well, Scott repeatedly proved his braind is not made of sponge). However, how can you say, what should be insured? Life? Well, naturally. Property? Yop! Health? Probably…But what about safety? Jobs? Education? Justice? The deeper you go the harder it is to define what is a subject of insurance and what not. Finally, following this idea, we would reconstruct something like communism. Where the government insurers you against your own “wrong” decisions…


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: